This study describes the narrative about school life of science-gifted students in an autonomous private high school, and analyzes the identity they have formed through a narrative inquiry method. Two science-gifted students who participated in this study, which is part of a longitudinal research, also participated in the study of ‘the high school entrance examination experience’. In the high school, each participant form a unique narrative identity. The first research participant formed an identity as a self-reflective learner with music . He grew up reflecting upon himself constantly from his friends behavior during school, and music played a major role in organizing his thoughts and managing his feelings. The second research participant form an identity as a ‘abilityist who lives to work. Among talented students, he was recognized as a “skilled person” by taking on difficult tasks that others avoided. The participants were able to create “differences attributable to proximity” at an autonomous high schools, but the positive differences they made lost their power due to the burden of college entrance exams. In order to emphasize the importance of positive difference creation, the researchers proposed a mindset to pursue the “meaning of life” from the “pursuit of happiness” and suggested a convergence of education, the current topic of education, also emphasizes the creation of differences.